EmailEmail
PrintPrint
Pittsburgh Brewing says it's in deep trouble
Tells PBGC it will go under unless it can drop pensions
Wednesday, June 29, 2005

Pittsburgh Brewing, whose Iron City beer has been a staple of Pittsburgh life for more than 140 years, is warning it will go out of business unless it is allowed to terminate a pension plan covering about 530 current and former employees.

The company has told the federal Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp. it has lost $1.2 million from operations over the last three years despite $1 million in cost reductions and forbearance by lenders, government agencies and others who have granted concessions to save it.

The assistance included $4.6 million of debt that was wiped clean, an 82-cent on the dollar settlement on long overdue water bills and state aid last year that was the only money Pittsburgh Brewing invested in its aging plant.

"Unless the plan is terminated, [Pittsburgh Brewing Co.] will be unable to continue in business," lawyers for the brewery told PBGC officials in a letter dated April 29.

The warnings were made in documents Pittsburgh Brewing filed with the PBGC in April to justify pulling the plug on its pension plan. The Post-Gazette obtained them under the federal Freedom of Information Act.

The agency provided the brewery's six-page case for terminating the plan as well as annual pension plan reports. It did not provide annual financial statements. The brewery told the agency it does not have audited financial statements because it cannot afford the $65,000 annual cost of hiring an auditor.

The Lawrenceville brewer, which employs about 250, hasn't made nearly $900,000 in required contributions to the pension plan since October. The plan has a deficit of more than $5.6 million.

Most companies file for bankruptcy in order to jettison their pension obligations. Pittsburgh Brewing is taking a different tack by trying to make a case based on financial distress.

Vice Chairman Joseph Piccirilli, who led the group of investors who purchased the brewery at a 1995 bankruptcy auction, believes that if Pittsburgh Brewing goes into bankruptcy, it won't emerge as an operating company. Vendors have warned they won't extend credit to the company if it seeks bankruptcy protection, the company said.

The pension plan in question covers salaried and hourly workers and pays about $1.6 million in benefits annually. Benefits were frozen when two plans were merged in 1995. Currently, the plan has enough money to pay about 70 cents for each $1 of benefits owed workers.

Additional quarterly pension contributions of $455,000 are required next month and again in October.

Pittsburgh Brewing's pension shortfall is a drop in the bucket for the PBGC, which is facing a $23 billion deficit from the unfunded pensions of airlines, steelmakers and other troubled companies.

The brewery said lenders won't finance $4 million in much-needed plant improvements because of the underfunded pension plan. The projects include replacing a 45-year-old keg system and $1.5 million to replace a 65-year-old boiler, which generates steam that powers equipment.

The company said it was recently fined $300,000 because the boiler doesn't meet pollution control requirements. More fines will be imposed if the boiler isn't replaced within 18 months, the company said.

The brewery also did not mention tax liens for unpaid unemployment compensation taxes. According to Allegheny County court documents, the state's Department of Labor and Industry is seeking $120,500 that was due for the first quarter. A similar lien was filed by the agency last year.

In making its case, the brewery blames previous owners for many of Pittsburgh Brewing's problems.

Piccirilli's group purchased the company for more than $31 million, including the assumption of more than $18 million in debt. The documents say Piccirilli provided $7 million of the $13.6 million cash required for the purchase and related costs.

First published on June 29, 2005 at 12:00 am
Len Boselovic can be reached at lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.
Correction/Clarification: (Published 6/29/05) It was incorrectly reported that Pittsburgh Brewing's unpaid sewage bills incorrectly said the money was owed to the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority. It's owed to the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, which reimburses Alcosan for unpaid bills, then begins collection efforts against the Alcosan customer.